Online reputation management for a local business comes down to three jobs: get a steady flow of honest reviews, reply to every one of them, and know what ranks when someone searches your name. There’s a fourth job nobody warns you about, which is ignoring the flood of “reputation” offers that will arrive once you have a website. Of the 1,094 entries in our own contact form since 2022, 948 were vendor pitches or spam. That’s 87%. Some of them were fake warnings about our reputation.
We’re going to use our own Google Business Profile as the example here, and it isn’t flattering. Here’s what to do with yours.
What ranks for your name is your reputation
Search your business name plus “reviews.” Whatever shows up on that first page is what a prospect sees right before they call you, or don’t. Ann Smarty has spent twenty years in SEO and now spends much of her time on exactly this:
“Being a brand is great, but no one talks about how… you lose control over it because stuff starts ranking for your name.”
Ann Smarty, on Unscripted SEO
Her point is that the branded search is the one that matters most, and it’s now the one AI tools run too. Before ChatGPT or Google’s AI Overviews recommend a business, they look up what people say about it. Jeremy’s version: a product flaw people complain about on Reddit used to be a social media problem. Now it shows up inside the search results, so it’s a search problem, and the fix might belong to your operations team, not your marketer.
A few things you can control on that first page:
- Your Google Business Profile. It’s usually the biggest thing on the page for a branded search. Keep it claimed, accurate and active.
- A reviews or testimonials page on your own site. We gave this tip at our 2019 reputation meetup and it still holds. You want your page to rank for “your name reviews,” not a third-party site that happens to show your one bad review first.
- The profiles that matter in your industry. Google, Facebook and Yelp for most local businesses, plus the niche ones. Avvo for lawyers, TripAdvisor for hospitality. If you’ve renamed your Facebook page recently, make sure the URL changed with it.
Our 33 reviews stopped in 2019, and that’s the lesson
2theTop’s Google profile has 33 reviews at 4.9 stars. The newest is from November 22, 2019. Most came from people who attended the free Nashville SEO meetup; when the room stopped filling every month, the reviews stopped too, and nobody built a habit to replace it.
When we searched “nashville web design” in Google Maps from our own office, the listings around ours held 105, 97 and 65 reviews. A high star rating with no new reviews in six years tells a buyer one of two things: you’ve stopped working, or you’ve stopped asking. Neither one helps. We dig into the map side of this in our local SEO strategies post.
How many reviews do you need? There’s no magic number. BrightLocal’s 2019 research put the average Google review count for top-3 local results at 47, but it varies wildly by industry, and it’s old. The better benchmark is the businesses currently showing above you, for your service, from where your customers actually search. Count theirs, check the date of their newest one, and you have your target.
Ask every customer, make it easy, and never pay for reviews
If you don’t ask, the only people who review you are the ones with strong feelings, and that usually means the unhappy ones. Asking is the whole strategy. Drew Dorenfest, who got into SEO through review work, automates the ask so nobody has to remember it:
“Sending that automatic thank you email with a Google review, Google Business Profile link to leave a review. They don’t have to do it, it just runs on autopilot.”
Drew Dorenfest, on Unscripted SEO
Here’s a simple version you can set up this week:
- Copy your review link from your Business Profile dashboard (“Ask for reviews”).
- Send it within a day of finishing the job, while the experience is fresh. Email or text both work.
- Put the same link on your invoice, your email signature and a small card at checkout.
- When a happy client says something nice in an email, ask if they’d post it as a review. They already wrote it.
Don’t pay for reviews, don’t offer a discount for them, and don’t let a vendor write them for you. Google has prohibited incentivized and fake reviews since at least 2011, and its content policy still does. It isn’t only a Google problem, either. In 2013 the New York Attorney General’s “Operation Clean Turf” settled with 19 companies over fake reviews, with fines from $2,500 to just under $100,000. Several of them were SEO and reputation firms.
Reply to every review, especially the bad ones
A reply is public. You’re writing it for the next hundred people who read the review, not only for the reviewer. Matt Tyner, CMO of Bone Dry Roofing, put responding to reviews at the top of his list of things a small business should do this week:
“You got to respond to those because those are customer conversations, right? It’s not just a review. It’s a conversation you’re having with a customer that is upset. So have that conversation, make it right.”
Matt Tyner, on Unscripted Small Business
What we’ve told meetup rooms for years about a negative review:
- Don’t reply while you’re angry. Wait a day.
- Reply when you got it wrong, when the facts in the review are wrong, or when you can fix it.
- Keep the public reply short and professional, then take the conversation offline with a phone number or email.
- If it’s a misunderstanding, state your policy plainly. If it’s a fair complaint, say what you changed.
- Thank the positive reviewers too. A one-line reply shows the profile is alive.
And anyone who promises to remove your bad Google reviews for a fee? That’s the next section.
Scam emails and fake SEO offers: what 948 pitches taught us
We exported every entry from our contact form, January 2022 to October 2026. Filters flagged the obvious junk, and we read the other 236 by hand to sort real buyers from pitches. Real sales leads fell from 35 in 2023 to 12 so far in 2026. The junk didn’t fall at all.

The patterns repeat so often you can learn them in five minutes:
| The pitch | What it says | How often we got it |
|---|---|---|
| “My email bounced” | “I tried emailing you, but it bounced for some reason… so I’m reaching out here instead.” Almost always a virtual assistant offer. | 58 times, 55 of them in 2026 |
| Virtual assistants | Offshore help with prospecting, CRM updates and drip campaigns, often pitched as AI-powered. | About 90, 73 in 2026 alone |
| Fake bad press | “I came across a very negative opinon online about 2thetopdesign.com” (their typo), plus a shortened link to the supposed source. | 15, all in 2024 |
| Fake site audit | “We’ve found serious issues on your website that could be hurting traffic, security, and rankings.” Reply to a Gmail address for the report. | At least 13 |
| Review bragging | An overseas SEO firm citing tens of thousands of five-star reviews as proof of results. | 9 review-themed pitches, all in 2024 |
| Lead lists and data | Millions of “verified prospects” or leads for sale. | About 14 |
The fake bad-press message is the one that targets reputation directly, and it’s built to scare you into clicking. There was no article. The link is the attack. Same with the “serious issues” audit: a real audit names the issues and shows the data, and nobody who found a real problem asks you to reply to a free Gmail account to hear about it.
The older version of this was plain phishing, and we’ve written up plenty over the years: a hacked friend’s Hotmail pushing a diet-pill site, a “Taco Bell coupon” posted to our web design meetup group by an account created minutes earlier, an “Australian Taxation Office” email telling us we’d filed our (nonexistent) Australian taxes wrong. The costumes change. The red flags don’t:
- You didn’t expect it, and it’s oddly urgent.
- It’s addressed to “Team,” “Dear Middle Tennessee Web Design” or a scraped variation of your name.
- The link is shortened, or hovering over it shows a domain that has nothing to do with the sender.
- The domain was registered days ago behind private registration.
- It wants you to reply somewhere other than the company it claims to be.
- A quick search of a sentence from the message turns up dozens of identical copies.
If you want to know whether your site actually has problems, get a real SEO audit from someone who’ll show you the Search Console data. If you want to know what you’re doing wrong on reviews and listings, start with the small business SEO mistakes we see most.
We’re starting our own review ask again this month, six years late. When’s the last time you asked a happy client for one? If you want help building the habit, our SEO package covers your profile and reviews, or send us a note. A real person reads it.
